Skip to main content

Federal Court Rules Corporate Transparency Act Unconstitutional

In the landmark case of the National Small Business Association et al. v. Janet Yellen et al., the United States District Court for the Northern District of Alabama the court found the Corporate Transparency Act (“CTA”) to be unconstitutional.

At the heart of this case was the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA), a piece of legislation embedded within the 2021 National Defense Authorization Act aimed at combating financial crimes such as money laundering and tax evasion by requiring corporations to disclose detailed information about their beneficial owners to the Treasury Department’s criminal enforcement arm. The plaintiffs argued that this requirement exceeded Congress’s constitutional authority and infringed upon several constitutional amendments.

The CTA’s broad requirements for reporting personal stakeholder information were deemed to lack a sufficient nexus to any enumerated power of Congress, thereby overstepping the constitutional limits on legislative power. For corporations and small businesses, this ruling may signal a temporary reprieve from new reporting requirements that many viewed as onerous and potentially invasive. However, the long-term implications of this decision are still unfolding. The government’s likely appeal means that the final word on the CTA and its requirements has yet to be written.

This case highlights the delicate balance between the government’s efforts to ensure transparency and combat financial crimes, and the constitutional rights of individuals and entities. It also raises important questions about the extent of federal power over corporate governance, traditionally a domain regulated by state law.

For our clients and interested parties, as this ruling only applies to the parties in the case, they should continue to complete the reporting requirements by December 31, 2024, Until the law is declared unconstitutional universally, the reporting requirements are still operative for other corporations.

The landscape of corporate reporting requirements is often complex and subject to change, particularly as new legislation is introduced and contested in the courts. As we continue to monitor the situation, we encourage you to follow our articles for updates. We are committed to providing timely and insightful analysis on how legal decisions such as this one may affect your business or community associations.

Posted in Community Association, Condominium Association, Court Decisions of Importance, Homeowners Association, Legislation
Related Articles:

DBPR’s Condominium Division Increases Disciplinary Civil Penalties Against Associations

Community Association Remedies When Tenants Ignore Rent Demands

Finally! Some Push Back on Short Term Rentals

Court Rules No Mulligans for Golf Course Investors

Your Tenant’s Water Leak Damaged My Unit – Now Pay Up – 4th DCA Says Otherwise

Subscribe to New Articles

Enter your email address below to be notified of future blog articles from AriasBosinger. Your email will never be shared and you may unsubscribe at any time.